It may have been the onslaught of the 2008 presidential election and of negative, spiteful political attack ads running that got companies thinking about using this approach to spur their sales stemming back from 2008 forward. As reported in the Wall Street Journal, “As the economy gets ugly, marketers are getting nasty too. From soup companies to pizza chains, marketers
are stepping up their so-called attack ads, calling out rivals by name, comparing products and poking fun at competitors.” The National Advertising Division of the Council of Better Business Bureaus – aka, the ad police – has seen complaints jump substantially; business owners and marketers are alleging they are the victims of misleading comparison ads. We have never used this strategy; it is best to market your differentiation and actually prove the differences.
“In a downturn (or stalled) economy, people are being more and more careful about how they are spending their money, and more than usual you have to make sure you are breaking through and giving your customer a reason to buy you,” explains Patrick Doyle, president of Domino’s USA.
He’s got a point, but “their brand sucks” is not going to do it. First of all, it’s not exactly a defensible positioning – it’s likely quite easy for your competitor to come right back and say, “No, no, YOUR brand sucks.”
Then the back and forth starts and pretty soon buyers have no idea who the ads are for or why they should buy either brand. Why go this route just to confuse the customer? “Attack ads,” says the Wall Street Journal, “when they get too intense, can confuse customers.” If your advertising
raises more questions than it answers, you’re going to get tuned out and lose in the marketing and sales battle.
What’s a responsible business leader to do? Perhaps the questionable economy has made an impact on your company. Or maybe you can see the light at the end of the tunnel, but aren’t sure exactly when and how to recover. In either case, the most important thing is to keep your wits about you and not succumb to five common mistakes companies often make when times are questionable.
1. Be smart and thrifty, but don’t panic.
The economy goes through cycles of expansion and contraction as seen throughout history. It’s what we all learned either in college economic courses or through reading economist outlooks. While we love the expansionary times, the contractions can be painful. If you’re smart, you have managed your balance sheet well and can ride out a period of slow or stalled growth. If not, you may have to make some cut backs. Just be careful to trim fat and avoid cutting muscle as much as possible.
2. Marketing is muscle, not fat.
Just as the savviest investors view downturn or flat markets as a time to buy when everyone else is selling, the savviest marketers know this is a great time to pick up market share. They understand that by maintaining budgets (or even increasing them) they may not come out ahead during the down or stalled times, but they can pick up market share that will pay off in the long run. Marketing dollars during this time are like gaining more oxygen on Mt. Everest. The less there is in the surrounding environment, the more valuable the amount you possess becomes. Cutting your marketing spending is a sure way to give ground to competitors who may be more aggressive during this time.
3. Don’t lose focus by chasing business you may not really want.
When customers get nervous about the economy, they cut back on their spending. For a company, that could mean fewer transactions, smaller purchases, or possibly both. If you try to broaden your core product or service appeal to please a wider target audience, chances are you will make your best customers even less satisfied, giving them one more reason to spend less. There is a reason why you don’t pursue certain types of customers when times are good, and that reason probably has not changed. Do your best to stick to your plans and enhance the value you provide to your best customers. They may decide to make their cutbacks in areas other than yours.
4. Avoid the Discount Game.
While it is easy to rationalize discounting during a questionable or flat economy, avoid it if at all possible. For your company’s sake - it helps to drive business - as well as for the sake of your customers as they may be struggling and need the help. But whether times are good or bad, discounting your product or service in the eyes of your customers may not be the best thing to do. There was a time in the late 1990s when McDonald’s and Burger King put their Big Macs and Whoppers on sale so often that they trained their customers never to pay full price. This created a profit margin problem from which it took years
to recover. If you need to make your products more affordable to generate volume, goodwill, or both, do so carefully and deliberately. But lower the price instead of offering a discount.
5. Don’t forget about the elephant in the room.
We live in a 24-hour, 7 days a week, information cycle. When news breaks, people know it, and economic news breaks every day. You don’t have to be an economist to know the business environment is still questionable right now, and the point is brought home in a personal way every time we go to the grocery store or fill up our gas tanks. Even if your company’s revenues have held up, your employees still feel the pressure of attrition and are nervous. Make sure your employees know you are on top of things and have a plan. There is no telling what lies ahead over the next several months or years. We may pull out of our economic rut more quickly than anticipated, or we may be in for a prolonged rough ride. Customers will still need to eat; they still need transportation, and still seek entertainment, clothing, vacations, equipment, pet food, perfume, office supplies, computer servers, and machinery. As the market tightens up, the best positioned players will survive and thrive. Avoid the mistakes above and you’re more likely to be one of them.
Share
Join us on